Stone Soup by Marcia Brown Picture Book Review

Stone Soup by Marcia Brown Picture Book Review by What My Kids Read

Marcia Brown’s version of Stone Soup is the one I grew up reading. Because Stone Soup is a folk tale, there are many versions in book form, but this 1947 Caldecott winner captures the feel of a European peasant folk tale. Maybe if Patricia Pollacco had illustrated a version of this story, I might have liked that one more, but, to me, this one is the best!

Please note that this post contains Amazon affiliate links, which means if you buy through my links, I will receive a percentage of the sale. It doesn’t cost you more, but it helps us out. Thanks!

Stone Soup is about 3 soldiers who are coming home from war. They are hungry and tired, but as they approach a small village, the villagers gather together and agree not to feed or house the soldiers. “Soldiers are always hunger. But we have little enough for ourselves.” They hide all the food and try to look hungry when the soldiers arrive.

Stone Soup by Marcia Brown Picture Book Review by What My Kids Read

Since the villagers are unwilling to give the soldiers any food or a place to stay, the soldiers play a trick on the villagers. Since the villagers apparently have no food, the soldiers will make soup from water and 3 stones. The villagers are curious, quickly bringing the largest pot they can find, buckets of water, and wood for a fire. As the soldiers begin to “cook” the stones, they make comments like, “Stones like this generally make good soup. But oh, if there were carrots, it would be much better.” A villager then says that maybe they could spare a carrot or two, coming back with a pile of carrots. Little by little, the soldiers trick the villagers into putting cabbages, potatoes, and beef into the stew.

Stone Soup by Marcia Brown Picture Book Review by What My Kids Read

Once the soup is ready, the villagers then think it would taste better with some bread, a roast, and cider. It turns into a feast in the village square, and they all eat and dance into the night. The villagers insist that the soldiers stay in the best beds in town after teaching them how to eat so well on 3 stones! The soldiers leave in the morning with well wishes while the villagers still don’t realize the lesson the soldiers actually taught them.

Stone Soup by Marcia Brown Picture Book Review by What My Kids Read

The illustrations are only in three colors, probably because of the era when it was published, but I think it also helps keep the focus on the story. When I checked this book out from the library this time to read it, we had just finished talking about hospitality in manners as a part of our Civics study. This story was a great tie-in, as we discussed how the villagers were not friendly or generous out of fear and greed. It’s also a great story to emphasize that sharing resources with others is a great way to make something better.

Stone Soup by Marcia Brown Picture Book Review by What My Kids Read

Although she did not first catch onto the trick the soldiers were playing on the villagers, Brontë really enjoyed this story. Here is what she had to say about Stone Soup:

If you’d like to read this book, I’m sure your library has it. If you want to purchase it, your local bookstore should have it in stock, but if you are planning a purchase on Amazon, would you please use our link?

Stone Soup

It won’t cost you extra and it helps us a little. Thanks!



  1. What a beloved classic this is! Actually, it was a Caldecott Honor book (silver medal) but Marcia Brown later won the Caldecott three times for Cinderella, Once a Mouse, and Shadow. If you haven’t read those, I heartily recommend them, especially Once a Mouse and Shadow. I’m a huge fan of this author/illustrator, who used a wide variety of illustration styles and media; her Caldecott winners are perfect examples of how diverse her work was. Thanks for reviewing this one!

So what do you think?

%d bloggers like this: